top of page

The Hidden Cost of Being the "Nice Woman" in Business

Writer: Samantha Hearne
Samantha Hearne
Nov 6
5 min read

There's a difference between wanting people to like you and needing them to like you. And that difference can have a bigger impact on your business than you might realise.


I see this in so many women in business, and I've experienced it myself. We want to be thoughtful, considerate, and make sure everyone is happy. We soften our opinions, avoid difficult conversations and sometimes make decisions based on one question: What will people think of me if I do this?


The problem is that when approval becomes a requirement, it starts influencing everything. Your pricing, your visibility, your boundaries, and even the goals you're willing to admit you have.


At some point, you have to decide whether you want everyone to like how you're building your business or whether you want to lead it. Because those two things won't always be compatible.


When Being Liked Starts Running Your Business

Think about how often you might hold yourself back because you're worried about someone else's reaction.


Maybe you want to increase your prices but worry existing clients will think you're too expensive. Maybe you've written a strong opinion but softened it before posting. Perhaps you want to say no to a client but find yourself writing an entire essay explaining why.


These situations might look unrelated, but they often have the same underlying fear: What will people think of me?


This is particularly common for women who have spent years being the peacekeeper. When you're used to anticipating how other people feel and keeping everyone comfortable, you can become incredibly skilled at making yourself easier for others to experience.


Empathy and emotional intelligence are strengths. But when you're spending so much time monitoring everyone else's reactions that you struggle to make decisions for yourself, those strengths can become limitations.


You can care about how people experience you without making yourself responsible for everyone's feelings.


The Problem Might Not Be Your Business Strategy

One thing I see regularly in my mentoring is women trying to solve the wrong problem.


They think they need better marketing, stronger boundaries, more visibility or a different pricing strategy. And sometimes they do. But often, there's something underneath the practical business problem that needs addressing first.


For example:

  • Pricing: You're afraid clients will think you're too expensive. This might be a fear of rejection rather than a pricing issue.

  • Visibility: You want to become more recognised but keep holding back your opinions. This might be a fear of being judged.

  • Boundaries: You struggle to say no because you don't want to disappoint anyone. This might be a fear of letting people down.

  • Selling: You avoid talking about your offers because you don't want to seem pushy. This might be about how you believe others perceive you.


This is why surface-level business advice can only take you so far. Another Reels course isn't going to fix a visibility problem rooted in a fear of being judged.


You need to understand what's actually driving the behaviour before you can find a solution that works. The quality of the solution depends on the quality of the diagnosis.


Excellence Isn't the Same as Over-Delivering

This is a big one for women who pride themselves on providing an exceptional client experience.


You want your clients to feel supported and looked after. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But there's a difference between delivering an excellent service and constantly giving more because you're afraid someone might be disappointed.


Excellence means delivering what you promised exceptionally well. Over-functioning means continually adding more because you need to make sure nobody could possibly be unhappy with you. You add another call, include another round of revisions or respond outside your working hours. Eventually, you're delivering twice what you promised and feeling frustrated that nobody seems particularly grateful.


A sustainable business needs boundaries, clear expectations, and defined deliverables. You can go above and beyond when it's appropriate, but it should come from a conscious business decision, not a fear that what you've already promised won't be enough.


The same applies to pricing. Your job isn't to create prices that everyone feels comfortable paying. It's to price strategically for the business you're building, the value you're delivering, and the financial reality of running that business.


Someone might think your offer is too expensive. That's okay. Someone else might see it and think it's exactly what they've been looking for.


You Can't Become a Thought Leader While Trying to Keep Everyone Happy

I find it interesting how many women tell me they want to grow their audience, become more visible, and be recognised as a thought leader. Then they create content designed to make sure everyone agrees with them.


Those goals don't really work together.


Becoming known requires becoming identifiable. People need to understand what you believe, what you stand for, and how you see things differently. You don't need to be controversial for attention. But you do need to be willing to communicate what you actually think.


If you constantly soften your message to make it more palatable, people have a much harder time understanding what makes you different.


The more distinctive you become, the more likely you are to attract people who resonate with your perspective and want to work with you.


This is also why good mentorship should challenge you. You don't need someone who agrees with every decision you make. You need someone willing to ask whether you're solving the right problem, making decisions out of fear, or holding yourself back from what you're capable of.


Sometimes growth requires a different perspective, not another strategy.


What Would You Change If You Weren't Worried About Being Disliked?

Being bold doesn't mean becoming harder, louder, or less considerate. Sometimes boldness is actually quite quiet. It's holding your prices, saying no without inventing an elaborate excuse, posting the opinion you've been sitting on, or admitting you have a big goal.


And you don't have to prove that you're a good mother and a serious businesswoman. You can love your children and love your work. You can have ambition and still be a present parent. You don't have to make your business smaller to make other people comfortable.


I want you to spend some time thinking about three questions:

  1. If I wasn't worried about being disliked, what would I change in my business? Would you increase your prices, let a client go, change your working hours or finally share that opinion?

  2. What am I afraid people will say about me? Have you spent years trying to make sure nobody could ever describe you in a particular way?

  3. Who would I become if I no longer needed everyone else to understand me?


That last question is the one I really want you to sit with.


You don't need to stop caring what people think. You just need to stop allowing every opinion to dictate your next move.


You don't have to become less kind to become more powerful. You don't have to become colder to become a strong leader. You just have to stop abandoning yourself to keep everyone else comfortable.


Ready to Make Your Next Shift?

If you're recognising some of these patterns in yourself, it's worth asking whether the business you're currently building is aligned with the woman you want to become.


Inside The Shift 2027, we're looking beyond surface-level business strategies and focusing on the decisions, changes, and shifts that will move you towards your next level.


Sometimes you don't need another tactic or template. You need to challenge the patterns keeping you in the same place.

Comments


bottom of page